The Point of View of the Universe: Sidgwick and Contemporary Ethics
What does the idea of taking 'the point of view of the universe' tell us about ethics? The great nineteenth-century utilitarian Henry Sidgwick used this metaphor to present what he took to be a self-evident moral truth: the good of one individual is of no more importance than the good of any other. Ethical judgments, he held, are objective truths that we can know by reason. The ethical axioms he took to be self-evident provide a foundation for utilitarianism. He supplements this foundation with an argument that nothing except states of consciousness have ultimate value, which led him to hold that pleasure is the only thing that is intrinsically good.
Are these claims defensible? Katarzyna de Lazari-Radek and Peter Singer test them against a variety of views held by contemporary writers in ethics, and conclude that they are. This book is therefore a defence of objectivism in ethics, and of hedonistic utilitarianism. The authors also explore, and in most cases support, Sidgwick's views on many other key questions in ethics: how to justify an ethical theory, the significance of an evolutionary explanation of our moral judgments, the choice between preference-utilitarianism and hedonistic utilitarianism, the conflict between self-interest and universal benevolence, whether something that it would be wrong to do openly can be right if kept secret, how demanding utilitarianism is, whether we should discount the future, or favor those who are worse off, the moral status of animals, and what is an optimum population.
Wat mensen zeggen - Een recensie schrijven
We hebben geen recensies gevonden op de gebruikelijke plaatsen.
A Biographical Prologue
1 What is Ethics?
2 Reason and Action
3 Intuition and the Morality of Common Sense
4 Justification in Ethics
5 The Axioms of Ethics
6 The Profoundest Problem of Ethics
7 The Origins of Ethics and the Unity of Practical Reason
Perfectionism and DesireBased Theory
Overige edities - Alles weergeven
accept Altruism animals argues argument axiom Bentham chapter claim common sense morality consciousness consequentialism consequentialist consider debunking defend Derek Parfit desire theory desire-based discussion distinction duty egoism esoteric morality evolutionary example existence experience machine externalist fact feelings foundationalism Gauthier Gert give happiness Hare hedonism hedonist Henry Sidgwick Hooker human idea impartial individual intuitionism intuitions judge justified Kahneman killing lead lives maximize means Methods of Ethics moral judgments moral rules moral theory moral truths morality of common motivation nature normative normative reason objection obligation one’s Parfit perfectionism philosophers pleasures and pains possible principle problem psychopaths question R. M. Hare rational rational egoism Rawls Reasons and Persons reasons for action refers reflective equilibrium reject seems self-evident self-interest Sidgwick says someone suggests tell Theory of Justice things tion tive utilitarianism utility virtue W. D. Ross well-being wrong